Warner Bros.’ second new Lord of the Rings film is very confusing following Gandalf’s confirmation

The Lord of the Rings is a historical franchise and has three more films in the pipeline, but the third is confusing after it was confirmed that Gandalf will likely star in it. A revival of The Lord of the Rings is extremely welcome, as is the reappearance of Gandalf, one of “Lord of the rings” best characters. But Gandalf’s appearance in Warner Bros.’ The upcoming planned film raises many questions. This includes Gandalf’s role, considering that most of his story by then has probably already been covered in other films.

Gandalf is not expected to appear in the 2024 anime film The War of the Rohirrimbut he’s almost confirmed for the next film, The hunt for Gollum, about Gandalf’s search for Gollum. Ian McKellen has already been asked by Warner Bros. to return as Gandalf The Hunt for Gollumand he expressed his enthusiasm (deadline). Lord of the rings Producer and writer Philippa Boyens confirmed that Gandalf is likely to appear in it The Hunt for Gollums follow-up film, however, did not confirm the film’s plot, making its premise confusing.

The return of Gandalf for a second new Lord of the Rings film makes the story confusing

Gandalf’s role in the second new LOTR film is unclear

Gandalf’s role in The Hunt for Gollum film is somewhat clear, but what role he might play in a sequel remains to be seen. Warner Bros. originally confirmed this below The War of the Rohirrima duo of new films would be released, suggesting continuity between the two. However, Philipa Boyens confirmed this The Hunt for Gollum “are not two films“ (Rich). From Boyens’ comments it appears that there is little to no connection between them The Hunt for Gollum and his successor, leaving Gandalf’s role in Warner Bros. third planned LotR Film uncertain.

If Warner Bros.’ third LotR The film, presumably scheduled for 2028 or a similar date, was a sequel to Hunt for GollumGandalf’s role could be suspected. Boyens confirmed this Rich The The Hunt for Gollums Story “falls after Bilbo’s birthday party and before the mines of Moria“and is a”specific part of an… untold story.“Told in two films, In this story, Gandalf could be chasing Gollum through MirkwoodRhovanion and Mordor. But as a separate endeavor Hunt for Gollumthe third film would likely tell a different Gandalf story, requiring a deep dive into the legendarium.

What Gandalf story another “Lord of the Rings” film could tell

There are a few Gandalf stories to tell

Below The War of the Rohirrim And The Hunt for Gollum, the next Lord of the rings The film could tell a Gandalf story from the early Third Age. Boyens confirmed that Warner Bros. is remaking the third Lord of the rings Film wouldn’t necessarily be a Hunt for Gollum sequel and even hinted that it might not necessarily be live-action. She said: “We have the absolute blast of a second film that would be incredible as an anime,The details remain obscure. Regardless of the format, the mysterious film could draw on Gandalf’s arrival in Middle-earth as source material.

Warner Bros.’ Hunt for Gollum Follow-up may not have enough source material to tell a story that takes place after the events of The Hunt for Gollum. Most of Gandalf’s most impressive moments in his late third age occur during Peter Jackson’s Lord of the rings And Hobbit Films. The film could use Gandalf’s first appearance in Middle-earth as a theme. Accordingly LotRs attachments, Gandalf arrived by ship in the Gray Havens around the year 1000 of the Third Age and pushed for an attack on Dol Guldur some 2,000 years later, which could make for an interesting film premise.

Is the Lord of the Rings franchise relying too much on Gandalf?

Warner Bros. might be overusing Gandalf

Gandalf’s mysterious appearance in one Lord of the rings Film tracking The Hunt for Gollum makes it look like the LotR The franchise may be relying too much on Gandalf. This film could tell the story of Gandalf’s early days in Middle-earth, or it could even essentially tell the story of Gandalf’s existence in the Timeless Halls. There is source material for the third new one Lord of the rings Movie to play with It is within his rights, but is only very briefly outlined and not fully developed. Perhaps Warner Bros. is exploiting Gandalf’s commercial appeal without a fair basis.

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
Seasons 1 and 2 can be streamed on Amazon Prime Video.

Creative integrity and fidelity are always elevated in relation to Lord of the rings Adaptations because high fantasy master JRR Tolkien created such a beloved story. And that’s how it should be – it’s good that fans will always hold Warner Bros. and Amazon Prime Video accountable Lord of the rings Productions. It could be that Gandalf will be used by Warner Bros. as… Lord of the rings mascot in a sense, guiding the audience into the cinema while Gandalf’s role was forced into the narrative.

Frodo actor Elijah Wood expressed his confidence
The Lord of the Rings
creative integrity for the future…

It’s possible that a Gandalf cameo could happen in Warner Bros.’ third planned Lord of the rings The film could involve an excessive deviation from Tolkien’s narrative, which would entail a compromise in fidelity. However, Boyens did not confirm that Gandalf will play a role in any of the upcoming films. Plus, Warner Bros. could acquire unique rights to relevant parts of the Legendariumlike Amazon did Rings of power. Frodo actor Elijah Wood expressed his confidence The Lord of the Rings creative integrity for the future and explains: “There are so many different stories they could tell” (Inverse).

Sources: deadline, Rich, Inverse